Brook Hollow Winery

“Never in my wildest dreams would I have imagined that I would own a winery,” says Paul Ritter, standing on the porch of the brand-new 3,200 square-foot building that houses his wine-making operation and storage in one half, and a tasting bar and retail outlet in the other. “I would welcome a half dozen more wineries like this within fifteen minutes. We need a nice wine trail like on Long Island or the Finger Lakes. It’s a great industry and a great time to be in it in New Jersey. More and more are coming online, and we’re all producing excellent wines. People are selecting the right grapes, ‘made’ for the area. Winemakers need to be spot-on with their skill. You need to know your grapes and what the can and can’t do.” The Brook Hollow Winery, in Knowlton Township, looks out over Ritter’s five-acre vineyard, then beyond to the Delaware Water Gap. “This porch is 104 feet long, and I can envision people sitting out here all afternoon. Everyone wants to reserve a chair on this porch.”

The Brook Hollow Winery, in Knowlton Township, looks out over Ritter’s vineyard, then beyond to the Delaware Water Gap.
Paul and Debbie Ritter at the tasting bar.

Brook Hollow Winery’s location is new, but the name is not. Ritter developed his winemaking skills as a hobby while he and his wife, Debbie, raised three girls and 2,000 grape vines in their yard, Paul working for New Jersey Fish and Wildlife as senior biologist. His degree in natural resources and secondary education as a biology teacher helped; there’s quite a bit of chemistry involved in making wine. Six years ago, Ritter approached his friend, farmer Dave Flitcroft, about leasing some land at near-by Brook Hollow Farm, a bountiful range of apple and peach orchards with a well-established clientele. Paul planted more grapevines there and set up a shop in a portion of Flitcroft’s retail barn. Ritter’s “guerilla marketing” savvy proved equal to his winemaking skills, and the business took off. The Ritters decided to go for it, researching, soil testing, then purchasing the lot along State Route 94 in Columbia. “The wines were selling themselves and we had to add something to that to make the package complete,” says Paul. “We had hoped to open last fall, but something about a hurricane blew that out of the water.”

Planting began at Brook Hollow Winery’s new location in 2012.

With their vines at home, another 4,000 grown at Dave’s farm moved to a new location, and 4,000 more planted last year at the winery, Brook Hollow has an inventory that will eventually supply all of their grapes. “Northern New Jersey is a challenge, but pick the right grape and, if Mother Nature’s good to you, you can make a nice wine,” says Ritter who has selected the hybrids most likely to do well here. “Frontenac, a hybrid created at the University of Minnesota especially for colder weather, does very well. The grapes make incredible deep dark wine with lots of layers. It’s almost too vegetative and demands lots of attention, pruning, etc., but it’s worth it.” Ritter uses another hybrid called GR7, a cross of Baco Noir and Buffalo created at Cornell. “You work with that grape and your hands are stained for weeks. That’s why it’s used a lot for blending wines that are deficient in color. We make it as a varietal, and bottle it as Proprietor’s Red. It was the first grape vine I ever planted, so I kind of fell in love with it.” Chambourcin, also grown at most other New Jersey wineries, finds use in more than drink. Brook Hollow’s Triple Chocolate Chambourcin Cake tastes like chocolate covered cherries.

Chambourcin grapes, a New Jersey standard, grown at Brook Hollow.

“I make dry wines,” explains Ritter. “A customer will go to our rack and see Cabernet Sauvignon and bring it over probably with a preconceived thought about what it should taste like. We always ask ‘Did you taste this specific wine?’ If they say no, we won’t sell it until they try it. Especially as a start up, I want to make sure that each customer will enjoy whatever he or she takes home. Our Cab Sauv, we age in American white oak barrels out of Pennsylvania, and it has an incredible vanilla taste from the interaction with the charred part of the barrel. Not everyone cares for that, although it’s our number one selling Red. People have driven all the way up from Cape May to get it. That’s better than any award.” Another of Brook Hollow’s most popular wines is not even made from grapes. One year, Ritter bought a bunch of cranberries down in South Jersey and made fifty gallons of dry cranberry wine. “It was out the door in two weeks. At first I was a bit offended; I wanted to be known for my dry reds. I would go home and complain to my wife that people were coming in for our non-grape wines.”

Whatever their preference, specially bred grapes or 100% fermented Jersey cranberries, Paul is proud of his customer base. “Anything you need—picking, pruning—send an email out and you immediately have an onslaught of volunteers. You need help bottling or need somebody to run a corker, they’re there for you. Volunteers are a big help, especially for a start-up business.” Now with a freshly-minted and expanded location, those customers will come for tastings and wine classes in a new solar-powered building, large events or weddings in the pavilion, or a lazy afternoon on the porch looking out over the vineyard, with a toast to the Water Gap.

Brook Hollow Winery
Click or call 908/496-8200

For information about upcoming events at this and other North Jersey wineries, visit Vintage North Jersey

Upcoming Evemts

  • August 4 • CLAM BAKE. Joining us this year for our clam bake will be Argyle Restaurant, specializing in the highest quality Scottish Fish n' Chips and many other fresh fish specials. 1 - 4pm. $50 pp.
  • October 6 • ANNUAL PIG ROAST. A fun filled day of great food, your favorite wines, live music. 1 - 4pm. $45 pp, advance sale only; wine available by the glass, $5..

Nearby accommodations and attractions

  • Blairstown Museum
  • View original artifacts, postcards, and correspondence that illustrate the history of the township and its inhabitants, including former resident and namesake John Insley Blair. Museum collections are on display on a rotating basis throughout the year, and lovely gift shop items are supplied and crafted by local companies and artists.

    26 Main Street, Blairstown 07825, 908/362-1371

  • Big Skylands Country
  • Warren County's Montana Mountain, Merrill Creek Reservoir, and the Pohatcong Valley is equally rewarding for students of history and devotees of the outdoors.

    , ,

  • Twenty Belvidere
  • An 1800s hillside manor for your private event offering overnight accommodations for up to sixteen guests. Twelve foot high ceilings, large three floor center staircase, pocket doors, butler's pantry...you get the idea! Perfect for your wedding party, corporate meeting, family gathering or just a weekend getaway with that special someone.

    20 Belvidere Ave., Oxford 07863, 908/-857-2054

  • 4 Track
  • Bike Sales, Service and Rentals - Hiking Gear and Supplies - Model Trains and Hobby Supply. Located on historic Main Street in Blairstown, 4 Track is only 1/8 mile from the Paulinskill Valley Rail Trail, a beautiful 26 mile cinder bed flat rail-trail, perfect for cycling or hiking! 4 Track is also a great starting point for a short hike on the Appalachian Trail with a full supply of gear and maps.

    15 Main St , Blairstown 07825, 908-362-5699

  • The Farm In Harmony
  • 7-acre military themed Corn Maze, with mini maze for little ones, open Wed.-Sun. through November 10.Fresh produceat farmstand or schedule pick-on-demand. Homemade soaps available online.Always a discount for Veterans with proper ID.

    231 Brainards Road, Harmony 08865, 908/283-0721

More...

Stay in the Loop!

Get our newsletter, This Week in the NJ Skylands, with updates, special offers and good ideas!

Read current newsletter

Privacy Statement